PARIS â" The French government said Monday that it would oppose General Electricâs friendly $13.5 billion offer for a large portion of Alstom, the countryâs largest industrial conglomerate, saying the deal should be reconfigured on a more equitable footing.
Alstom announced last week that its board had unanimously endorsed General Electricâs offer for its power generation and transmission businesses, but the government, concerned about having a national industrial champion disappear into the vastness of the American colossus, has balked.
ââWhile it is natural that G.E. would be interested in Alstomâs energy business,ââ Franceâs economy minister, Arnaud Montebourg, said in a letter to Jeffrey R. Immelt, the G.E. chairman and chief executive, ââthe government would like to examine with you the means of achieving a balanced partnership, rejecting a pure and simple acquisition, which would lead to Alstomâs disappearing and being broken up.ââ
The governmentâs legal means for stopping a deal would appear to be limited, though it could refuse to approve such an investment on national security grounds. While the government does not hold Alstom shares, the company is considered important enough to have received a 2.2 billion-euro bailout in 2005. And Mr. Montebourg noted in the letter Monday that the government was Alstomâs most important customer.
Alstomâs energy units, which make turbines for nuclear, coal and gas power plants, as well as the grid infrastructure to deliver electricity, contribute about three-quarters of its 20 billion euros, or about $30 billion, in the companyâs annual sales.
The letter, sent by Mr. Montebourg on behalf of President François Hollande and obtained by The New York Times, continued: ââAs it stands, we unfortunately cannot support the proposals you have made,ââ adding, ââbased solely on the acquisition of Alstomâs activities in the energy domain.ââ
In the letter, Mr. Montebourg reiterated Alstomâs importance to the countryâs nuclear industry, saying it justified a close examination of any foreign investments, as ââFrance must maintain its technological sovereignty.ââ
The company has been suffering from sagging demand for big energy projects in Europe and from competition from fast-growing Asian rivals, including in the nuclear industry, where interest has faltered since the Fukushima disaster.
G.E.âs plan would leave Alstom with only its transportation business, which makes TGV trains and other rail equipment and infrastructure.
Mr. Montebourg, who was surprised to learn of the advanced Alstom-G.E. negotiations by a news report less than two weeks ago, has suggested that Siemens, the giant German conglomerate, would make a better partner for Alstom.
Siemens, which fears the invasion of its European turf by G.E., said last week that it planned to make a bid, the broad outlines of which would be a transfer of Siemensâs transportation business to Alstom in exchange for the energy businesses sought by G.E.
Mr. Montebourg, in the letter Monday, expressed concern about the ââseparation and isolationââ of the transport business, calling on General Electric to transfer its own transport businesses, including its freight train and signaling business, valued at $3.9 billion, ââto assure a certain global futureââ for Alstom.
A G.E. spokesman said he did not know about the letter and could not immediately comment. Alstom did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Patrick Kron, Alstomâs chairman and chief executive, has said that Alstom would consider both offers.
Mr. Montebourg also called on Mr. Immelt to lay out G.E.âs commitment to maintaining and creating jobs in France, and that they ââare not ephemeral.ââ